Personalized Gifts

 Sports, Toys & Games

 Toys & Games

 Jigsaw Puzzles

Nostalgic Christmas Eve Puzzle. Pretty digital ai art illustration of a vintage Christmas tree, old-fashioned tricycle, icicles in the window looking out a snowy night. 

Old-Fashioned Nostalgic Christmas Morning Jigsaw Puzzle

Ai watercolor illustration of a scene on a rustic farm with a black horse and cardinal and a wood fence decorated in pine cones, berries and garland on a Christmas winter day.

Festive Black Horse and Cardinal Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle

 Sweet Christmas stickers with kids gleefully opening up their gift from Santa under the tree. Mid-century retro nostalgic memories with vintage vibes.

Sweet Nostalgic Children on Christmas to and from Jigsaw Puzzle

Cute holiday puppy playing in the snow on a winter day Christmas puzzle.

Christmas Puppy in the Snow on a Winter Day Jigsaw Puzzle

Christmas puzzle. Ai watercolor illustration of a scene on a rustic farm with a brown and white painted or pinto horse and cardinals and a wood fence decorated in pine cones, berries and garland on a Christmas winter day.

Pretty Brown and White Horse Rustic Farm Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle

A cute watercolor illustration of a snowman in front of a suburban Victorian house in a sweet cozy neighborhood. Snowman has blue scarf and tophat on.

Cute Whimsical Snowman in the Front Yard Christmas Jigsaw Puzzle

Illustration of African-American fairies or angels decorating a little Christmas tree in an enchanted magical forest. Beautiful ethereal cottage core fairytale background.

African-American Fairy Decorating Christmas Tree Jigsaw Puzzle

Virgin Mary with Baby Jesus in a tile mosaic stained glass style. Bright, beautiful and colorful.

Virgin Mary and Baby Jesus Stained Glass Jigsaw Puzzle

Pretty whimsical village all festive with Christmas lights and decorations in pink and blue to give the little town a vintage enchanted cozy vibe. 

Whimsical Folk Village Christmas Square Sticker

Sweet vintage Mr and Mrs Santa Claus (African-American) baking cookies in the kitchen. Cute ai art that gives you that nostalgic Christmas vibe. 

Mr and Mrs Clause Cute Christmas  Tissue Paper

Remember Christmas 2020 Santa Claus and Elf in Face Masks during the Coronavirus pandemic nostalgic keepsake ornament.

Goodbye 2020 Santa and  Elf in Facemask Ceramic Ornament

On the first side of this pretty aqua blue ornament is a butterfly sitting on a snowflake. On the back you can add a personal message to whoever you are buying it for.

Butterfly Personal Message Christmas Keepsake Ornament

Personalized Christmas ornament. Cute watercolor whimsical winter gnomes in red and blue. Wishing you a festive Christmas topped with joy!

Holiday Gnomes Personalized Christmas Ceramic Ornament

Personalized Christmas stickers or envelope seals.  Add a festive touch with these personalized Christmas stickers or Christmas card envelope seals.

Personalized Merry Christmas Snowflake Classic Round Sticker

Add your dog's name to this cute dog paw print in the personalize area and snowflake background.

Old-Fashioned Nostalgic Christmas Morning Jigsaw Puzzle

Old-Fashioned Nostalgic Christmas Morning Jigsaw Puzzle

More from Feeling Like Christmas

Other jigsaw puzzles from various stores